News online for Encinitas, Calif.

North Coast Current

EDITORIAL: Muir on the right side of Encinitas council vote

North Coast Current

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






What qualifies someone to be appointed to the Encinitas City Council? Two or three years living in the city with little public footprint outside a brief stint on the Parks and Recreation Commission. The one sitting council member to question this? Mark Muir.

As a troika of City Council members — Mayor Catherine Blakespear, Deputy Mayor Tony Kranz and Councilwoman Tasha Boerner Horvath — voted to appoint resident Joe Mosca out of 13 applicants to a vacant seat on the dais Jan. 11, Muir stood out as the one member willing to stand outside the majority in the name of community experience and continuity.

Muir’s logical motion to appoint Tony Brandenburg — a politically active member of the community for decades who received nearly 11,000 votes for council himself in November — was quietly stopped as the rest of the council pushed for Mosca, despite some of their own questions about Mosca’s temperament and a potential conflict of interest.

Brandenburg and Mosca draw a sharp contrast in community experience.

Brandenburg, a retired judge and an Encinitas resident for more than 50 years, has extensive community experience, including seats on the Olivenhain Town Council, Encinitas Planning Commission and Encinitas Union School District Board of Trustees.

Mosca served two years on the city’s Parks and Recreation Commission. The number of years he has lived in Encinitas has been the subject of debate. Some critics and news reports put the number of years at two or nearly three. Mosca himself corrected Muir on Jan. 11, saying “a few years.”

Brandenburg served as a judge for nearly two decades in the San Diego Municipal and Superior Courts, and has also served as chief judge of the Intertribal Court of Southern California, which resolves disputes in a culturally sensitive process among participating tribes. His work in that effort earned him Eastern Connecticut University’s Distinguished Alumnus Award and an honorary degree, according to a university profile.

“Tony, you mentioned in your campaign deep community roots. By God, I’ve got ’em,” Brandenburg told the council, nodding to Tony Kranz.

The North Coast Current keeps an open mind as Mosca joins the council. As a resident here, he has just as much right to seek office as anyone, whether he has lived here for two years or 20.

So the question, then, isn’t his length of time in the city. The question is whether he has a significant grasp of the community’s issues and whether he has the proper temperament for office.

That remains unclear.

The fact that Mosca was elected twice to the City Council of Sierra Madre, near Los Angeles, is not an automatic qualifier for City Council in Encinitas. Process should not trump substance.

On Jan. 11, Kranz asked Mosca about a potential conflict of interest as an employee of San Diego Gas & Electric at a time when the council mulls the idea of pursuing community choice energy, which would offer more choices in providers than the just the main utility.

Mosca’s response: “We’re all employed. We all have jobs.”

Blakespear, following up on questioning by Muir, asked Mosca about “playing well with others,” in reference to Sierra Madre City Council meeting videos circulated by critics claiming they show he lacks the proper temperament for office.

Mosca’s response: “My approach in terms of negative politics, I’ve always tried to go above, rise above.”

Both responses, in the Current’s opinion, are at best boilerplate, as was his beginning statement to the council: “I’m passionate about our wonderful community.”

Mosca may well make a fine City Council member — and there is optimism that he will — but the Current must question how a few years of Encinitas residency, which encompasses work on one commission, qualifies him for appointment without the vetting of a campaign where voters can weigh such issues for themselves.

Ultimately, the winner in this non-election is Councilman Mark Muir, who was willing to go against his colleagues and put forth a choice, Tony Brandenburg, with a clear track record of experience to back him up — in Encinitas.

Editorials solely represent the opinions of North Coast Current ownership. The Current welcomes letters to the editor and longer commentaries sharing opposing points of view.

Print Friendly

7 Comments

7 Responses to “EDITORIAL: Muir on the right side of Encinitas council vote”

  1. Lisa Shaffer on January 12th, 2017 10:52 pm

    I have to say that I question the logic of this opinion piece. Tony Brandenburg ran for City Council three times and lost each time, most recently he came in last. The voters had the opportunity to elect him to the Council and chose other people instead. I have nothing against Mr. Brandenburg, but I would not have chosen him from the list of applicants as the most qualified.

    Mr. Mosca, on the other hand, while not deeply rooted in Encinitas, does understand governance, was elected twice in Sierra Madre as the top vote-getter, and as soon as he moved here, he offered his time and talent as a commissioner and then as a member of the Coastal Mobility and Livability Working Group. He can hit the ground running and make a meaningful contribution quickly.

    [Reply]

  2. Bill on January 13th, 2017 6:42 am

    Another sour grapes response from Shaffer. I applied for the group she is speaking about and was not accepted. I have lived here 10 years but Mosca got right on? Rumor has it he fit what Lisa wanted in the first place. Personally, I think the article is spot on. But Shaffer will still spin her stories whether they are true or not.

    [Reply]

  3. Sheila S. Cameron, former Mayor of Encinitas on January 13th, 2017 10:56 am

    Thank you, Mark Muir!

    [Reply]

  4. chris swanner on January 13th, 2017 12:20 pm

    So Lisa Shaffer chose not to run but she chose her successor. I feel sorry for my friend Mark Muir as he will be on the wrong end of most every vote. Grind it out Chief.

    [Reply]

  5. Bill on January 13th, 2017 1:52 pm

    Kind of strange isn’t it Chris? We will have to support Mark as much as we can.

    [Reply]

  6. Lynn Marr on January 15th, 2017 6:18 am

    We need to give Mosca a chance, now; we have no choice. Muir showed courage in his vote, and logic, also respect for the public.

    Lisa Shaffer, despite the fact that Brandenburg lost, he did get 11,000 votes. And how many did Bruce Ehlers receive when he ran, years ago? I know I voted for Bruce, as did my spouse. I believe part of the reason that Mosca was appointed is because he has influence/connections within our local Democratic Party? Council Members are supposed to be non-partisan, but they usually hope for, and rely upon, an endorsement by the local “party machines.”

    One thing, Tony Brandenburg was not a Judge of the Superior or Municipal Court. He is a retired Commissioner; he did hear cases in small claims court, as a Commissioner. The media keeps blurring this distinction. Brandenburg was a tribal judge, which is different. I was unaware that Brandenburg was a Trustee for EUSD? Does anyone know when he was elected to that position?

    [Reply]

    North Coast Current Reply:

    Greetings Lynn:

    Reporting from the Los Angeles Times San Diego bureau in 1986 about a land density dispute names him as president of the EUSD board at that time.

    http://articles.latimes.com/1986-08-08/local/me-1927_1_school-district

    Thank you for reading.

    [Reply]

The North Coast Current provides this Comments feature as a way for readers to share viewpoints on stories and issues. The Comments window is open for seven days after a story is published. The Current welcomes letters to the editor on older stories. To submit a letter online, go to www.northcoastcurrent.com/letters, or email them to letters@northcoastcurrent.com. The North Coast Current cares about fostering constructive, engaging community discussions. Therefore, the Current moderates comments. Editors reserve the right to accept or reject comments as they see fit. Comments must be civil and constructive regardless of political or religious leanings, and must be specific to the story being commented about. Comments containing threats will be rejected without exception, and may be forwarded to law enforcement depending on the nature and severity of the threat. As published material accessible to the public, the North Coast Current will occasionally republish posted comments in the Dialogue section of its printed editions. By commenting here, as with submitting letters to the editor, readers grant the right to publish comments in the North Coast Current print edition.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




News online for Encinitas, Calif.
EDITORIAL: Muir on the right side of Encinitas council vote